Ink & Colour
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

 Ink at the Heart of a Fountain Pen 

Picture
Picture
Picture

Lamy - Petrol and Mont Blanc - Petrol Blue

30/7/2019

0 Comments

 
I have been away for a while so no recent posts and the amount of ink I have just keeps creeping up so I thought I would review two inks today both said to be petrol but quite different colours.  
The first ink is Lamy petrol released in 2017 to coincide with the release of the Lamy Safari in petrol.  It was an immediately difficult ink to buy in NZ as it was quite popular and sold out very quickly.  It may still be available overseas, I did manage to track down some cartridges and cut up a couple for the purpose of this review. 
The second ink is Mont Blanc petrol blue recently released as their colour of the year.  Mont Blanc inks are not easy to obtain in NZ but I have just discovered (others may have known before me) they have an official online shop that ships to NZ.  You pay the advertised price there was no additional postage.  This makes it a reasonable option as I paid NZ$61, the same ink in Australia is NZ$57 but I would have to pay p+p, in the USA it retails for approximately NZ$66 and again p+p would need to be applied.  
​I thought I would have nothing to say about ‘why’ this name for an ink but there is some history behind ‘petrol’ blue.  When most people think of petrol they probably think of it being an amber or golden yellow colour.
Picture

The colour of petrol is actually dependent on the country in which you live.  Fuel dyes are added to low taxed petrol to deter its use in applications intended for higher taxed ones.  The most common colours for untaxed or low taxed fuels are usually browns or reds.  The higher taxed fuels are known as clear or white.
The colouring of the cheaper fuels has led to fuel laundering in some parts of the world.  During the political unrest in Ireland paramilitary groups had plants on both sides of the border to strip cheap fuel of its colourant in order to on-sell at a much higher price.  The volumes that could be laundered in these plants in one day were not insignificant.
With respect to ‘petrol blue’ all I could find is that it may have pertained to compounds derived from petrol such as paraffin.  These are often coloured blue, the most obvious example is kerosene aka paraffin oil which is commonly blue.
Picture
Picture
Picture
Kerosene doesn’t remind me of these inks.


​
​The Lamy ink comes in the standard Lamy 50ml bottle.  The colour on the cap is quite true to the colour of the ink, it looks more like a dark green / teal colour.
Picture
Picture
​



​Chromatography was revealing as it appears to be a mix of green and at least three shades of blue including a bright turquoise colour.
Unfortunately I spilt something on this hence it is cut in half to show the 'undamaged' portion.

The col-o-ring swatch confirmed for me that this tends towards a green colour.  It dried to a deep / dark green teal.   ​I quite liked the colour and it looked even nicer on Tomoe River.  Despite the ink being green based it reminds me of the ocean, what I imagine the colour is when it is very deep and you are far from land.  
Picture
Col-o-ring
Picture
Tomoe

My writing tests were done on Rhodia, Tomoe river and Midori cotton paper in that order.  I used a Lamy Al-star with a medium nib.
The writing was darkest on the Rhodia, the shading was best on Tomoe but for me the best colour was on Midori where it was a dark green
Picture
Rhodia
Picture
Tomoe river
Picture
Midori cotton

There was no feathering or bleeding on any of the papers.
In summary –
Saturation – high
Shading – very good
Sheen – none
Flow – very good, no problems at all, started very quickly
Drying – acceptable but could be better
Waterfast – surprisingly good, for a not waterproof ink
Picture
A few drops of water and the inks starts to run
Picture
First held under running water, significant run off
Picture
Held under a tap until there is no more or little ink run off and there is a surprising amount still on the paper

The Mont Blanc ink comes in the standard small MB bottle ie 50ml glass bottle  in a square box that has a hard inner drawer containing the bottle.  I find MB inks tend to be quite true to the colour on the box.
Picture
Picture

​
​
On opening the bottle the colour has hints of turquoise but tends to what I would call steel blue.
Picture
Picture



​Chromatography revealed about three shades of blue, some green but not as green dominant as the Lamy ink, here the blues dominate.

The col-o-ring was also more blue, in fact very close to what you would find on the internet if you googled ‘petrol blue’.  There is no sheen which is a bit of a shame.   Tomoe river was surprising as the ink dried to a ‘washed out’ turquoise.  The col-o-ring does more for this ink than the best of the fountain pen friendly papers.
Picture
Col-o-ring
Picture
Tomoe river
 
For the writing test I used the same three papers as before Rhodia, Tomoe river, Midori cotton.  There was some nice shading on the rhodia but it did not dry particularly quickly.  
Picture
Rhodia
Picture
 
​On Tomoe it is definitely a blue ink unlike the greener Lamy, again a lot of nice shading but still not that quick to dry.  And like the Lamy ink I liked this best on Midori paper.
Picture
Tomoe river
Picture
Midori

Again no feathering or bleeding on any of the papers. 
In summary –
Saturation – high
Shading – very good
Sheen – none
Flow – good, Lamy flow was better at the start, I had to prime my pen with the MB, didn’t with the Lamy.
Drying – acceptable but could be better
Waterfast – surprisingly good, but not as good as the Lamy
Picture
One drop of water and immediate ink run
Picture
First held under tap, significant run-off but also quite a lot of ink loss where the first drop was placed.
Picture
Never really got to the point were there wasn't a lot of ink run-off, there is also a lot of colour loss

I have not yet swatched all the inks I own but out of those I have I could find nothing similar to the Lamy petrol but I could find at least 2 identical to the Mont Blanc ink.  The only difference between the three is there is a hint of red sheen with the Blackstone Sydney harbour.  If I had known this before I started, as much as I like the MB ink I would have saved the $$ and probably bought something else since I already have two inks identical to this.  I like the Mont Blanc ink but think the Lamy is better value for money.
Picture

To finish the two inks side  by side.  In every photo Mont Blanc is on the left
Picture
Chromatography
Picture
Col-o-ring
Picture
Tomoe river
Picture
Midori cotton
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Ink Brands

    All
    3 Oysters
    Birmingham Pen Co.
    Blackstone
    Bungbox
    Diamine
    Fountain Pens
    Hypercolors
    J Herbin
    Krishna
    Lamy
    Louis Vuitton
    Mont Blanc
    Monteverde
    Nemosine
    Noodlers
    Online
    PenBBS
    Pilot Iroshizuku
    Private Reserve
    Robert Oster
    Sailor - Ink Studio
    Sailor - Jentle
    Sailor - Kingdom Note
    Sailor - Kobe Story
    Shosaikan
    Taccia
    TAG Stationery
    TWSBI
    Vinta Inks
    Wancher
    Waterman

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact